A nonprofit related party transaction policy is a written framework that defines what counts as an insider deal, requires disclosure and recusal, and documents board approval before the organization signs, pays or hires.Done well liability. This guide walks boards, treasurers and compliance officers through spotting, approving and recording these transactions in plain English.
Key Takeaways
- A related party transaction is any deal between the nonprofit and an insider or their family or business.
- Disclosure, recusal and independent board approval are the three non-negotiable controls.
- Reasonable compensation and comparable-market pricing are your strongest defenses.
- Document everything contemporaneously; the IRS expects written records, not recollections.
- Tie the policy to your conflict of interest framework and annual disclosure cycle.
- Most violations start as small, unnoticed deals, not deliberate self-dealing.
What counts as a related party transaction?
A related party transaction is any financial or contractual arrangement between a nonprofit and a person or entity with a close connection to it. The IRS does not use one single definition, but the concept is consistent across Form 990, intermediate sanctions rules and state nonprofit corporation law.
Here is a quotable definition your board can adopt nearly verbatim:
A related party transaction is any transaction, agreement or arrangement in which a nonprofit organization provides or receives moneya related party.Related parties include officershich a related party holds a significant ownership or control interest. The defining feature is not wrongdoing but the presence of a personal interest that could influence, or appear to influence, the organization's decision. Such transactions are not automatically prohibited; they are permitted only when disclosed, reviewed by disinterested decision-makers, priced at fair market value, and documented in the minutes.
Who is a "related party" under common rules?
- Directors, officers, trustees and key employees
- Family members (spouse) of the above
- Businesses owned or controlled by those individuals, often at a 35 percent or greater threshold in Form 990 reporting
- Substantial contributors and their controlled entities
- Other nonprofits under common control or with overlapping leadership
Related party transactions vs. prohibited self-dealing
Not every insider deal is illegal. The distinction matters for nonprofit self dealing rules. Private foundations face strict self-dealing prohibitions under Internal Revenue Code Section 4941, where most insider transactions are simply forbidden. Public charities face the intermediate sanctions regime under Section 4958, which allows reasonable transactions but penalizes excess benefit transactions with excise taxes on the insider and, in some cases, on approving managers.
| Feature | Private foundation | Public charity |
|---|---|---|
| Core rule | Self-dealing largely prohibited | Allowed if reasonable and approved |
| Governing code | IRC 4941 | IRC 4958 |
| Penalty focus | Excise taxes on disqualified persons | Excise taxes on excess benefit and managers |
| Practical test | Is it permitted at all? | Is it fair, disclosed and approved? |
Common examples boards miss
Most related party transactions nonprofit boards overlook are ordinary, recurring arrangements, not dramatic fraud. The risk hides in routine vendor choices, compensation decisions and shared resources.
Everyday deals that trigger disclosure
- Hiring a board member's firm for legal, accounting, construction or IT work
- Leasing office space from a director or a director's family LLC
- Paying a founder or relative a salary, stipend or consulting fee
- Buying event catering, printing or supplies from an insider's business
- Selling, leasing or transferring property between the nonprofit and an insider
- Loans to or from officers, even interest-free and short-term
- Sharing staff, vehicles or equipment with a related organization
Compensation and the excess benefit trap
Excess benefit transaction prevention starts with compensation. If a disqualified person receives more than reasonable value for services, the excess is taxable to them, and approving managers who knowingly approved it can also face penalties. The IRS safe harbor, often called the rebuttable presumption, requires approval by disinterested directors, reliance on comparable market data, and contemporaneous documentation. Miss any leg of that tripod and the presumption collapses.
Approval and recusal procedures that hold up
A defensible approval process has four moves:disclose. Anything less invites IRS scrutiny and donor distrust. Build these steps directly into your nonprofit conflict of interest transactions workflow.
Step-by-step approval framework
- Disclose in writing before negotiation begins, using an annual disclosure form and a transaction-specific notice.
- Recuse the interested party from discussion, deliberation and the vote; record the recusal in the minutes.
- Benchmark the deal against at least two or three comparable quotes, salary surveys or appraisals.
- Approve by disinterested majority of the board or a designated audit or governance committee.
- Document contemporaneously:who disclosed.
- Review annually to confirm the arrangement still reflects market value and mission need.
When should the board say no?
Decline the transaction when no disinterested quorum exists, when comparable pricing cannot be established, when the deal primarily benefits the insider, or when a cheaper or cleaner alternative exists. A policy that never produces a "no" is not a control; it is decoration.
Documentation the IRS expects
Related party transaction disclosure lives or dies on paper. Form 990 asks directly about transactions with interested persons, family members and controlled entities, and the IRS compares those answers against your minutes and records.
The minimum documentation file
- Signed annual conflict of interest and disclosure forms from every director, officer and key employee
- Board or committee minutes showing recusal, deliberation and the vote count
- Comparable market data: quotes, appraisals, salary surveys or independent valuations
- Written contracts with clear scope, pricing and term
- A transaction log reviewed by the audit or governance committee each year
Keep these records for at least the period your state's nonprofit act and IRS guidance require, commonly seven years or longer. If your organization files Form 990, remember that Schedule L specifically captures transactions with interested persons; sloppy records here are a common examination trigger.
Annual disclosure workflow
A once-a-year paper exercise is not enough, but an annual cycle anchors everything else. The goal is a predictable rhythm so disclosures surface before deals are signed, not after.
A practical 12-month calendar
- January: distribute and collect signed disclosure forms from all covered persons.
- February: governance committee reviews forms, flags conflicts and updates the register.
- Quarterly: standing agenda item asking whether any new related party deal has emerged.
- Before any signing: transaction-specific disclosure and recusal vote.
- Year-end: reconcile the transaction log against Form 990 Schedule L before filing.
Tools help here. The GoWithFund Organizations hub lets verified organizations centralize profiles, governance documents and transparency signals in one place, which makes it easier to keep disclosure records consistent and visible to stakeholders. It is a supporting tool, not a substitute for legal advice.
Linking policy to your conflict of interest framework
A related party transaction policy should not sit in a drawer alone. It works best as one chapter of a broader conflict of interest framework that covers gifts, outside employment, confidential information and board conduct.
How the pieces fit together
- Conflict of interest policy: defines duties of loyalty and disclosure obligations.
- Related party transaction policy: operationalizes approval, recusal and documentation for specific deals.
- Whistleblower policy: gives staff a safe channel to report undisclosed insider arrangements.
- Document retention policy: ensures minutes, comparisons and contracts survive an audit.
Adopt the policy by board resolution, train directors annually, and review it every two to three years against IRS guidance and your state nonprofit corporation act. When in doubt on a specific deal, consult a nonprofit attorney; this guide is general information, not legal advice.







