A nonprofit gift acceptance policy is a written board-approved document that defines which donations your organization will accept. It protects your mission, your tax-exempt status, and your board from awkward or costly surprises. This guide walks founders, executive directors, and treasurers through what to include, with sample sections you can adapt.
- A gift acceptance policy prevents mission drift, legal risk, and board conflict before a problematic gift arrives.
- Cover cash, in-kind, restricted, planned, and unusual gifts — not just checks and credit cards.
- Define a clear approval workflow with dollar thresholds and board sign-off for exceptions.
- Review the policy annually and after any gift that tests its limits.
- Pair the policy with clean donor records and acknowledgment workflows.
Key Takeaways
- A gift acceptance policy prevents mission drift, legal risk, and board conflict before a problematic gift arrives.
- Cover cash— not just checks and credit cards.
- Define a clear approval workflow with dollar thresholds and board sign-off for exceptions.
- Review the policy annually and after any gift that tests its limits.
- Pair the policy with clean donor records and acknowledgment workflows.
Why Does Every Nonprofit Need a Gift Acceptance Policy?
Every nonprofit needs a gift acceptance policy because donations can carry strings, liabilities, and reputational costs that cash value alone never reveals. A gift acceptance policy is a formal set of rules — adopted by the board — that tells staff andvolunteers exactly how to evaluatehey reach your account.
Without one, decisions get made ad hoc, often under pressure from a generous donor. That is how small charities end up owning a vacant building they cannot afford to maintain, or accepting a restricted gift that quietly redirects the mission. The policy moves the hard conversation from the moment of the gift to a calm board meeting months earlier.
It also supports compliance. The IRS requires written acknowledgment for cash gifts of $250 or more, and donors claiming non-cash deductions above $500 generally file Form 8283, with qualified appraisals typically required above $5,000. Your policy should align acknowledgment and valuation practices with these thresholds so donors get accurate receipts and your books stay clean.
What Gifts Should You Accept, Decline, or Review Case by Case?
Accept routine gifts that align with your mission and budget; decline gifts that create legal, financial, or reputational risk; route everything else to a review committee. The table below is a practical starting framework you can adapt in your own nonprofit gift acceptance guidelines.
| Gift type | Default stance | Key considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Cash and checks | Accept | Standard acknowledgment; verify donor intent in writing |
| Credit card / online gifts | Accept | Watch processing fees; confirm recurring-gift terms |
| Publicly traded stock | Accept | Sell promptly; confirm no donor restrictions on sale |
| Closely held stock / LLC interests | Review | Illiquid; may carry liabilities; needs legal review |
| Real estate | Review | Environmental |
| Vehicles, equipment, inventory | Review | Storage |
| Gifts from controversial sources | Review or decline | Reputational risk; board discretion required |
| Gifts requiring illegal or unethical action | Decline | Non-negotiable; document the refusal |
Gifts to decline outright
Decline gifts that are illegal, require the organization to violate its charter or tax-exempt purpose, or would obligate you to spend more than the gift is worth. Also decline gifts conditioned on endorsing a product, political candidate, or private interest. A written refusal, delivered graciously, is far better than an accepted gift you later regret.
Gifts to review case by case
Real estateeview bucket. Each can be valuable, but each can hide environmental liabilities, illiquidity, or unrelated business income tax exposure. Require a written analysis — often with outside counsel or an appraiser — before acceptance.
How Should You Handle Restricted, In-Kind, and Unusual Gifts?
Restricted gifts should be accepted only when the restriction matches an existing program or a board-approved new one; in-kind gifts need documented fair market value; unusual gifts need legal and financial review before signing anything. These three categories cause most gift-acceptance disputes, so your policy must address each explicitly.
Restricted gifts
A restricted gift is one the donor limits to a specific purpose, program, or time period. Your policy should state that restrictions must be in writing, must align with your mission, and must be feasible within your budget. Include a clause allowing the board to re-designate funds if the restricted purpose becomes impossible — and get donor consent for that clause up front, in the gift agreement itself.
In-kind gifts
In-kind gifts are non-cash contributions: goods, services, or use of property. Note that donated services are generally not deductible for the donor, though they may be reportable in some contexts. For goods, record fair market value with reasonable documentation — a donor invoice, comparable sales, or an appraisal for high-value items. If your nonprofit reports more than $25,000 in non-cash contributions in a year, IRS Form 990 Schedule M applies, so your recordkeeping must support it.
Unusual and planned gifts
Bequestsh carry distinct rules. Your policy should name who reviews them (typically the board treasurer plus outside counsel), what disclosures donors receive, and when the organization must decline — for example, when a gift annuity's payout rate would strain reserves.

What Approval Workflow and Board Sign-Off Should You Use?
Use a tiered approval workflow: staff accept routine gifts, the executive director or treasurer approves mid-tier gifts, and the board approves exceptions and anything outside standard categories. Written thresholds remove ambiguity and make donor conversations faster and more confident.
- Tier 1 — Staff acceptance: cash, checks, and online gifts under a set amount (for example, $5,000) with no restrictions.
- Tier 2 — Officer approval: restricted gifts, in-kind gifts, or gifts between $5,000 and $25,000, approved by the executive director and treasurer jointly.
- Tier 3 — Board approval: real estate, business interests, gifts above $25ies.
- Documentation: every Tier 2 and Tier 3 decision is minuted, with the gift agreement attached.
- Annual review: the board revisits the policy yearly and after any contested gift.
This structure mirrors how mature nonprofits handle risk: routine decisions stay fast, and consequential ones get collective judgment. It also gives development staff a clean answer when a donor asks, "Can you accept this?" — the answer is a process, not a personal opinion.
What Should a Gift Acceptance Policy Template Include?
A solid gift acceptance policy template includes purpose. Below are sample sections you can adapt, written in plain policy language.
Sample section: purpose and scope
"This policy governs the solicitation[Organization]. It applies to board members, staff, and volunteers acting on the organization's behalf. Its purpose is to protect the organization's mission, assets, and tax-exempt status."
Sample section: donor intent and restrictions
"All restricted gifts must be documented in a written gift agreement signed by the donor and an authorized officer. Restrictions must align with the organization's mission and approved programs. If a restricted purpose becomes unlawful re-designate the funds, or apply to a court of competent jurisdiction where required by law."
Sample section: valuation and acknowledgment
"The organization will acknowledge all gifts in writing. Acknowledgments for gifts of $250 or more will include the information required by IRS regulations. The organization does not appraise gifts; donors are responsible for obtaining appraisals required for their own tax filings, including Form 8283 for non-cash gifts over $500."
Sample section: conflicts and declination
"The organization will decline any gift that is illegal, inconsistent with its mission, or likely to generate costs exceeding its value. Declinations are documented in writing and reported to the board at its next meeting."
Adapt these sections with your counsel, then attach them to your bylaws or board policy manual. A gift acceptance policy template is a starting point — your mission, state law, and donor base should shape the final text.
How Do You Implement and Maintain the Policy?
Implement the policy by board adoption, staff training, and donor-facing documentation — then maintain it through annual review and post-gift debriefs. A policy that lives in a drawer protects no one.
- Adopt formally: board resolution, recorded in the minutes, with an effective date.
- Train everyone: development staff, finance, and board members should know the tiers and the referral path for unusual gifts.
- Align systems: your donor database and acknowledgment letters should reflect the policy's thresholds and language.
- Review annually: check IRS thresholds, state charitable solicitation rules, and your own experience with edge cases.
- Debrief hard cases: after any declined or contested gift, ask what the policy missed and amend it.
Clean execution matters as much as drafting. Tools that centralize donor records, recurring gifts, and acknowledgment workflows — such as GoWithFund's nonprofit tools, which charge 0% platform fees and support recurring donors — make it far easier to honor the policy consistently as gift volume grows.





