Nonprofit board giving policy examples range from simple "100 percent board giving" expectations to formal give-or-get commitments with dollar thresholds. The right policy is one your board will actually adopt:clear cannot give personally but can raise funds. This guide walks through proven models, sample wording, and a rollout plan for reluctant boards.
Key Takeaways
- Written board giving policies outperform verbal expectations every time.
- Three models dominate: give-only, get-only, and give-or-get.
- Sample wording and thresholds matter more than policy length.
- Reluctant members need options, not ultimatums.
- Track board gifts alongside recurring donors for a full picture.
- Review the policy annually and tie it to board recruitment.
Why do boards need a written giving policy?
A written policy converts an awkward, unspoken expectation into a shared standard.Without onetful. With one, every member knows the commitment before joining, and the board can model the philanthropy it asks of others.
Funders notice. Many grantmakers ask whether 100 percent of the board gives before awarding support, because board giving signals genuine ownership of the mission. BoardSource, the leading U.S. board governance organization, has long emphasized board engagement in resource development as a core responsibility, and its research consistently links board participation in fundraising to organizational health. Exact percentages vary by survey year, so treat any single figure as directional rather than definitive.
A written policy also protects relationships. When expectations live in a document adopted by vote, no individual feels singled out. The conversation shifts from "why won't you give?" to "how will you meet our shared commitment?"
Give, get, or give-or-get: which model fits your board?
The three standard board fundraising policy examples are give-only, get-only, and give-or-get. Give-or-get is the most common because it honors both capacity and connection: members either contribute personally, raise the equivalent from others, or do both.
| Model | How it works | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Give-only | Every member makes a personal gift | Boards with strong personal capacity | Excludes connectors with limited wealth |
| Get-only | Members raise funds from their networks | Boards heavy on influencers and marketers | Can feel transactional; weak personal skin in the game |
| Give-or-get | Give personally, raise the amount, or combine both | Most small and mid-size nonprofits | Needs clear definitions of what counts as "get" |
What does a give or get policy actually require?
A board give or get policy sets a minimum annual commitment, usually a dollar figure, that each member satisfies through personal giving, solicited gifts, or a combination. For example, a $2,500 give-or-get might mean a $2,500 personal gift, $2,500 raised from others, or $1,000 given plus $1,500 raised. The policy should define qualifying gifts, the recognition window, and how progress is reported.
Is 100 percent board giving realistic?
Yes, and it is the most widely cited benchmark in nonprofit governance. "100 percent board giving" means every board member makes some personal gift, not that every gift is equal. A $50 gift from a student member and a $10,000 gift from a major donor both count. The point is participation, not parity. Many organizations adopt a modest floor (for example, $100 to $500) precisely so 100 percent participation is achievable.

What should sample policy language look like?
Good sample language is short, specific, and adopted by board vote. Below is a template you can adapt. Replace bracketed figures with your own thresholds and have counsel or your governance committee review before adoption.
"Each board member is expected to make an annual personal gift to the organization at a level that is meaningful to them, with a minimum of $[amount] per fiscal year. Members may fulfill this commitment through personal giving, by securing gifts from others totaling the same amount, or through a combination of both. The board chair and executive director will review progress quarterly and report aggregate participation to the full board. Members experiencing financial hardship may request a confidential alternative arrangement from the governance committee. This policy is reviewed annually."
Notice what this wording does. It sets a floor without shaming, allows give-or-get flexibility, builds in confidentiality for hardship, and assigns review responsibility. Avoid language that ties giving to voting rights or board standing; that creates legal and cultural problems in most jurisdictions and poisons trust.
How do you set the right threshold?
Anchor the number to your budget and board composition, not to peer organizations you admire. A common approach: set the give-or-get at roughly 1 to 2 percent of the annual operating budget divided across board seats, or simply pick a round figure your median member can meet. If half the board cannot meet the floor, the floor is wrong, not the board.
How do you handle board members who cannot give?
Handle it with dignity, structure, and confidentiality. A member who cannot give personally can still give time. The policy should name these alternatives explicitly so no one has to confess hardship in a public meeting.
Use a simple three-step framework:
- Normalize the conversation early. Discuss the policy during recruitment, before anyone joins.
- Offer a confidential pathway. The governance committee or board chair handles exceptions privately.
- Count non-cash contributions. Documented introductions, event hosting, and pro bono services can satisfy the spirit of the policy.
What you should not do is quietly waive the policy for some members while enforcing it for others. Inconsistent enforcement breeds cynicism faster than a strict policy ever could.
How do you roll out a new policy without awkwardness?
Roll it out as a governance upgrade, not a fundraising demand. Announce it as part of a broader board effectiveness effort:clearer roles. Sequencing matters because giving lands better inside a package of professionalism.
A practical rollout checklist:
- Draft the policy with the governance committee, not the development director alone.
- Share a one-page FAQ with the board before the vote.
- Vote formally and record it in the minutes.
- Brief new recruits on the policy during onboarding.
- Report aggregate participation (never individual amounts) quarterly.
- Review and adjust thresholds after 12 months.
Expect one or two difficult conversations. That is normal. Most resistance dissolves when members see the policy applied evenly and tied to mission impact rather than to anyone's personal wealth.
How do you track board gifts alongside other donors?
Track board giving in the same system you use for all donors, with a board tag or segment, so participation is visible without exposing individual amounts to the full board. Report only aggregate figures publicly: for example, "14 of 16 board members gave this fiscal year."
This is where your donor infrastructure matters. If your recurring giving runs through a platform like GoWithFund, which charges 0% platform fees and is built around recurring donors, you can segment board members as a donor cohort, monitor retention, and see whether board giving grows alongside your broader recurring base. That visibility turns the policy from a compliance exercise into a culture metric. GoWithFund's nonprofit tools are worth a look if you want board and general donor data in one place without platform fees eating small gifts.
One honest caveat: no tool fixes a reluctant board. Software tracks behavior; only leadership shapes it. Use the data to celebrate progress, not to shame laggards.








