Matching gift donor outreach is the practice of proactively telling donors that their employer may match their charitable gift, then guiding them through the submission process. Done well, it turns one donation into two with no extra ask. This guide covers why donors miss out— everything development staff and fundraising volunteers need to run a reliable matching gift campaign.
Key Takeaways
- Most eligible donors never submit a matching gift request simply because they do not know their employer offers one.
- Proactive outreach — email, receipts, and post-gift follow-ups — consistently outperforms passive mentions on a donation page.
- Matching gift software can automate eligibility checks and reminders at scale.
- Timing matters: mention matching gifts at the moment of giving and again within 48 hours.
- Track submission rates, not just matches received, to improve your matching gift strategy.
What Are Matching Gifts and Why Donors Miss Out?
A matching gift is a corporate philanthropy program in which an employer matches an employee's charitable donation, often dollar-for-dollar and sometimes at a 2:1 ratio. The employee donates, then submits a short request to their employer, and the company sends a second gift to the nonprofit. It is one of the few fundraising levers that doubles revenue without asking the donor for more money.
So why do so many matches go unclaimed? The most common reason is awareness. Donors frequently do not know their employer offers a program, do not know the process, or assume it is not worth the effort. Double the Donation, a widely cited industry source, estimates that billions of dollars in matching gift funds go unclaimed each year and that a large share of eligible donors never submit a request. Treat those figures as informed industry estimates rather than audited totals — but the direction is consistent across nonprofit experience: the money exists, and donors leave it on the table.
The awareness gap in practice
In day-to-day fundraising, the failure pattern is predictable. A donor gives $250, feels good, and moves on. Nobody mentions that their employer matches up to $1,000 per year. The donor never searches for the program. The nonprofit never follows up. The match evaporates. Matching gift promotion closes that gap with three simple moves: tell donors before they give, remind them immediately after, and make the submission steps effortless.
How to Find Companies with Matching Gift Programs
You find matching gift companies by combining employer data you already collect with dedicated lookup tools. Start with your donor database: employer name is one of the highest-value fields you can capture on a donation form, and even partial data reveals patterns across your file.
A practical research workflow
- Audit your donor file. Export employer names and count frequency. Your top 20 employers likely represent a large share of givable matches.
- Check public program directories. Many large employers publish matching gift guidelines on their corporate responsibility pages.
- Use a matching gift database or software. Tools such as Double the Donation, 360MatchPro, and similar platforms maintain searchable employer databases with submission links and forms.
- Ask donors directly. A single line on your donation form — "Does your employer match gifts?" — surfaces eligibility you would never find otherwise.
- Verify before you promise. Program rules change; always confirm current ratios and deadlines on the employer's official page or through your software provider.
One honest caveat: no database is complete. Smaller employers and newer programs are often missing, so treat lookups as a strong starting point, not a guarantee, and invite donors to check with their HR or community relations team.
Email Templates for Matching Gift Outreach
The most effective matching gift emails are short, specific, and sent at the right moment. Below are three templates you can adapt. Keep each under 150 words, lead with the donor's impact, and include one clear call to action.
Template 1: Post-gift thank-you with a match prompt
Hi [First Name], thank you for your generous gift of [amount] to [Organization]. Did you know your employer may match it? Many companies match donations dollar-for-dollar. Search your employer at [lookup link] or reply to this email and we will help. It takes about five minutes and doubles your impact.
Template 2: Pre-campaign matching gift promotion
Hi [First Name], as our [campaign name] kicks off, here is a way to double your gift at no extra cost. If your employer offers matching gifts, your [amount] could become [amount x2]. Check your eligibility here: [lookup link]. Questions? Just reply — we are happy to walk you through it.
Template 3: Reminder for unsubmitted matches
Hi [First Name], a quick reminder: our records show your employer may match your recent gift, but we have not received the match yet. The request usually takes under ten minutes. Here is the link: [lookup link]. If you have already submitted, thank you — please disregard this note.
Matching gift best practices for email
- Send the first nudge within 24–48 hours of the gift, while motivation is high.
- Personalize with the donor's name, gift amount, and employer when known.
- One call to action per email; multiple links dilute clicks.
- Follow up once or twice, then stop — over-mailing erodes trust.
- Segment by employer so messaging reflects actual program rules.
Using Matching Gift Software to Automate
Matching gift software automates the eligibility checkhing gift promotion without adding headcount. Manual outreach works for a few dozen donors; automation is what makes it work for thousands.

What automation typically handles
| Function | Manual approach | With matching gift software |
|---|---|---|
| Eligibility lookup | Staff search employer websites | Donor self-serves via embedded search |
| Post-gift prompt | One-off thank-you email | Automatic email triggered by the gift |
| Reminders | Calendar-based manual follow-up | Scheduled nudges until submission or opt-out |
| Tracking | Spreadsheet reconciliation | Dashboard of pending, submitted, and received matches |
When evaluating tools, prioritize database coverage for employers your donors actually work for, integration with your donation platform and CRM, and reporting you can act on. Matching gift automation is not set-and-forget: review unmatched submissions monthly and refresh templates quarterly.
Timing Your Matching Gift Appeals
The best time to mention matching gifts is at the moment of giving, with reinforcement within 48 hours and again before the employer's submission deadline. Timing is the cheapest optimization in any matching gift campaign — it costs nothing and compounds every other tactic.
A timing framework that works
- Pre-gift: mention matching on the donation page and in campaign appeals.
- At gift: show a lookup widget on the confirmation screen.
- 0–48 hours after: send the thank-you email with the match prompt.
- 7–14 days after: one reminder if no submission is recorded.
- Year-end: a final nudge before December 31, when many employer deadlines fall.
For active peer-to-peer or crowdfunding campaigns, weave matching gift donor communication into your regular donor updates. GoWithFund campaigns make this natural: sharing tools, milestone tracking, and donor updates keep supporters engaged, and a milestone announcement is an ideal moment to remind donors their employer can double the gift behind that milestone.
Measuring the Impact of Matching Gift Campaigns
Measure matching gift campaigns on submission rate, match revenue, and cost per acquired match — not just total dollars raised. A campaign that generates awareness but no submissions is a messaging problem; one that generates submissions but no received funds is a process or follow-up problem.
Core metrics to track
- Eligibility rate: share of donors whose employers offer programs.
- Submission rate: share of eligible donors who submit a request.
- Match revenue: dollars received from corporate matching gifts.
- Time to match: days from donation to received match.
- Email performance: open and click rates on matching gift emails.
Review these monthly during campaigns and quarterly otherwise.If submission rates lag. If you cannot yet measure submissions, start there — even a simple spreadsheet beats guessing, and most matching gift software will generate this reporting automatically.







