GoWithFund
💡Fundraising Tips• Donor Conversion, Pitch Storytelling, Campaign Velocity & Analytics

Fundraising Tips for Board Members: 10 Plays

That turn governance into giving: scripts, expectations, and tracking to activate your board fast.

GoWithFund Editorial Team
GoWithFund Editorial Team
••7 min read
Nonprofit board members reviewing a fundraising campaign plan together at a conference table

Fundraising tips for board members boil down to three moves: set explicit giving expectations, give every member a specific low-pressure role, and track their activity like any other campaign metric. Boards under-give not because members lack generosity, but because no one ever defined the job. This guide gives executive directors and board chairs the scripts, structures, and accountability rhythms to fix that.

💡
Key takeaways
  • Adopt a written board giving policy with 100% participation as the goal
  • Assign specific plays like thank-you calls and warm introductions, not vague asks
  • Use short, practiced scripts to remove fear from donor conversations
  • Track board activity with GoWithFund milestones and a monthly dashboard
  • Match plays to member personalities to boost follow-through
  • Review progress quarterly and correct course privately, not publicly

Key Takeaways

  • 100% board giving is the standard expectation most funders look for.
  • Assign specific plays, not vague "help fundraise" requests.
  • Use board-to-board scripts for peer asks and thank-yous.
  • Track board activity with milestones, not guilt.
  • Review board fundraising metrics quarterly, like any KPI.

Why Do Boards Under-Give, and How Do You Fix It?

Boards under-give because fundraising was never written into the role description. Many members joined to govern, not to solicit, and no one corrected that assumption. The fix is structural: define the board fundraising responsibilities in writing, onboard members against them, and review them annually.

BoardSource, the leading research and support organization for nonprofit boards, has long recommended that every board member make a personally meaningful annual gift and that boards pursue 100% participation. Funders and grantmakers routinely ask for board giving percentages, so this is not cosmetic. A board that gives signals belief in the mission.

The second failure is vagueness. "Everyone should help with fundraising" produces nothing. "Each member will make two thank-you calls and one introduction per quarter" produces results. Specificity is the entire game.

The three root causes

  • Unclear expectations: giving and outreach were never defined at recruitment.
  • No skills support: members fear rejection and were never given scripts.
  • No accountability: activity is never measured or discussed.

Setting Clear Board Giving Expectations

Board giving expectations should be written, signed, and revisited annually. A good policy states a minimum personal gift (or a "give or get" alternative), expected outreach activity, and how participation is reported. Clarity before recruitment prevents awkward conversations after.

A board giving policy is a short written document that defines what each member is expected to contribute financially and through outreach each year. It typically covers a minimum annual giftgress. It is not a legal contract; it is a shared standard that makes expectations explicit so no member is surprised and no chair has to improvise accountability.

Here is a simple comparison of common approaches:

ApproachHow it worksBest forWatch out for
Minimum giftFixed annual amount per memberSmall boards, clear budgetsCan exclude lower-income members
Give or getGive personally or raise the equivalentBoards with strong networksHarder to verify "gets"
Personally meaningful giftMember sets own amount, 100% participationMixed-income boardsNeeds honest self-reporting
Activity-basedDefined outreach tasks per quarterBoards new to fundraisingMust be paired with giving

Whichever model you choosere joining.

10 Fundraising Plays Board Members Can Run

The best fundraising tips for board members are specific, repeatable plays rather than abstract encouragement. Each play below is low-pressure, takes under two hours, and maps to a real donor touchpoint. Assign one or two per member per quarter.

  1. Make the first gift. Give before asking anyone else to.
  2. Thank-you calls. Call three donors within 48 hours of their gift.
  3. Handwritten notes. Send five personal notes after an event.
  4. Warm introductions. Introduce the ED to two contacts per quarter.
  5. Host a small gathering. A coffee or dinner with 6-10 prospects.
  6. Share the campaign. Post the GoWithFund campaign link with a personal note.
  7. Match a gift. Pledge a small match to unlock momentum.
  8. Door-open meetings. Attend one donor meeting with the ED.
  9. Stewardship visits. Meet a longtime donor to hear their story.
  10. Recruit one peer. Nominate a future board member or fundraiser.

Notice what is missing: cold solicitation. Board members rarely need to ask strangers for money. Their value is warmth, credibility, and gratitude.

Board member making a donor thank-you call with a handwritten note nearby

Matching plays to personalities

Introverts thrive at thank-you calls and handwritten notes. Connectors excel at introductions and gatherings. Analytical members can own milestone tracking and reporting. Matching plays to temperament is the fastest way to get real participation.

Scripts for Board-to-Board and Donor Asks

Scripts remove the fear that keeps board members silent. The goal is not to sound polished; it is to sound like yourself, with a clear ask. Practice these aloud once, then adapt them.

The peer ask (board member to friend)

"I joined the board of [org] because [one-sentence reason]. We're raising [goal] for [specific outcome]. Would you consider a gift of [amount]? I'd be glad to answer questions or just send you the link."

The thank-you call

"Hi [name], this is [you] from the board of [org]. I wanted to thank you personally for your gift. Because of it, [specific impact]. No ask today — just gratitude."

The introduction email

"[Friend], I'd like you to meet [ED name] at [org]. They do [one line]. I think you'd value the work. Open to a 20-minute call?"

Keep every script under 60 seconds spoken. If a member can say it naturally, they will actually use it. Role-play at one board meeting per quarter; ten minutes of practice beats a binder of theory.

Tracking Board Activity with GoWithFund Milestones

What gets measured gets done. GoWithFund campaigns include milestone trackingboard accountability. Set 3-5 campaign milestones, assign board plays to each, and review progress monthly.

A simple rhythm works: at each board meeting, spend ten minutes on a one-page dashboard showing gifts made. Celebrate completions publicly; address gaps privately with the chair. This is encouragement with structure, not surveillance.

A 90-day activation checklist

  1. Week 1: Adopt a written board giving policy; confirm 100% participation goal.
  2. Week 2: Survey members on preferred plays and comfort levels.
  3. Week 3: Assign two plays per member; share scripts.
  4. Week 4: Launch or refresh the GoWithFund campaign with milestones.
  5. Weeks 5-12: Monthly 10-minute dashboard review; adjust assignments.
  6. Day 90: Debrief, thank members, set next-quarter targets.

If your board has never tracked fundraising activity, start with participation counts, not dollar amounts. Behavior change precedes revenue.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even well-meaning boards stumble on the same three errors. First, recruiting members without disclosing fundraising duties, then acting surprised when they disengage. Second, equating fundraising with asking for money. Third, reviewing results only at year-end, when it is too late to correct course.

Avoid public shaming at all costs. Private, specific, kind accountability from the chair outperforms public pressure every time. And never let one enthusiastic member carry the whole board; distribute plays so the workload is visible and fair.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are realistic fundraising tips for board members at small nonprofits?

Start with thank-you calls, personal notes, and warm introductions rather than cold asks. Assign two specific plays per member per quarter and track them on a simple dashboard. Small boards win through consistency, not volume.

Should every board member be required to give?

Yes — 100% board giving is the widely recommended standard, and many grantmakers ask for it. The amount can be personally meaningful rather than fixed, but participation should be universal and documented annually.

What is a give-or-get policy?

A give-or-get policy lets members either make a personal gift or secure an equivalent amount from their network. It works well for well-connected boards but requires honest reporting and clear definitions of what counts as a "get."

How much time should board fundraising take?

Two to four hours per month is realistic for most members. Thank-you calls, notes, and one introduction fit easily into that window, and GoWithFund milestone tracking keeps the effort visible without adding meetings.

How do you handle a board member who refuses to fundraise?

Have a private conversation with the chair to understand the barrier, then reassign to a comfortable play like thank-you calls. If refusal persists after support and clear expectations, it is a governance conversation about whether the role is a fit.

Can board members fundraise without asking for money?

Absolutely.Thanking donorsfundraising. Many of the highest-impact board activities involve gratitude and connection, not solicitation.

Conclusion

Fundraising tips for board members only work when they become habit:written expectations. Start with the 90-day checklist, pick two plays per member, and review progress monthly. When you are ready to give your board a shared campaign to rally around, launch or refresh your effort with GoWithFund campaigns — the sharing tools and milestone tracking make board accountability simple and motivating.

Direct Answers & Search Q&A

Frequently asked questions

6 Questions & Answers
Q1What are realistic fundraising tips for board members at small nonprofits?

Start with thank-you calls, personal notes, and warm introductions rather than cold asks. Assign two specific plays per member per quarter and track them on a simple dashboard. Small boards win through consistency, not volume.

Q2Should every board member be required to give?

Yes — 100% board giving is the widely recommended standard, and many grantmakers ask for it. The amount can be personally meaningful rather than fixed, but participation should be universal and documented annually.

Q3What is a give-or-get policy?

A give-or-get policy lets members either make a personal gift or secure an equivalent amount from their network. It works well for well-connected boards but requires honest reporting and clear definitions of what counts as a get.

Q4How much time should board fundraising take?

Two to four hours per month is realistic for most members. Thank-you calls, notes, and one introduction fit easily into that window, and milestone tracking keeps the effort visible without adding meetings.

Q5How do you handle a board member who refuses to fundraise?

Have a private conversation with the chair to understand the barrier, then reassign to a comfortable play like thank-you calls. If refusal persists after support and clear expectations, it becomes a governance conversation about role fit.

Q6Can board members fundraise without asking for money?

Absolutely. Thanking donors, making introductions, hosting gatherings, and sharing campaign links are all fundraising. Many of the highest-impact board activities involve gratitude and connection, not solicitation.

GoWithFund Editorial Team
Verified E-E-A-T Author

GoWithFund Editorial Team

Staff Contributor

Published on behalf of GoWithFund Inc., a registered U.S. 501(c)(3) tax-exempt public charity in Idaho (EIN: 33-1243835 | Idaho SOS #5902503). Articles are reviewed for statutory compliance under IRS Internal Revenue Code Section 170.

Related Topics

#fundraising tips for board members#board giving expectations#nonprofit board fundraising role#board member donor outreach#board fundraising responsibilities#nonprofit governance#board engagement
Recommended Reading
Explore all Fundraising Tips guides
Families gathered at a school PTA fundraising event with a donation table and speaker
💡 Fundraising Tips
Nov 21, 2026•7 min read

Fundraising Tips for Pta Events That Raise More

Fundraising tips for PTA events: outreach scripts, event-night asks, and milestones tracking to raise more with less stress.

GoWithFund Editorial Team

GoWithFund Editorial Team

Staff Contributor

Read
Volunteers planning a community fundraising campaign around a table with milestone cards and a laptop
💡 Fundraising Tips
Nov 21, 2026•9 min read

How to Be A Good Fundraiser: 9 Habits That Work

9 habits, scripts, and mindset shifts that help you raise more and keep donors engaged.

GoWithFund Editorial Team

GoWithFund Editorial Team

Staff Contributor

Read
Why 0% Platform Fee Crowdfunding Maximizes Donor Trust and Yield - GoWithFund Fundraising Tips Guide Cover Visual
💡 Fundraising Tips
Nov 21, 2026•5 min read

% Percent Platform Fee Crowdfunding Strategy

Maximize donor trust and yield with 0% platform fee crowdfunding, increasing average gift size and donor participation, under IRS IRC § 170 and §.

GoWithFund Support

GoWithFund Support

Director, GoWithFund Inc.

Read